Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

College void of scholarly thinking

Correspondent

Published: Saturday, October 17, 2009

Updated: Sunday, October 18, 2009 23:10

Derrick McMahon

Keenan Doanes

Derrick McMahon

I'm not at home on a college campus, or at least that's the way I have felt for some time now. My dreams of going to college started when I was a little boy. I have always anticipated the day when I could go off to college and learn everything there was to learn in the world.

I wanted to be like the great thinkers that I read about in the books my grandmother gave me as a child. But throughout my time here, I've learned college can be a very lonely experience for an intellectual. Whenever I encounter "college educated" people, I always wonder how can they be so closed minded. How can they be so uncritical of the world around them? How can they be so unconcerned?

I arrived on Florida A&M's campus with all of the excitement and thirst for knowledge that a student can possibly have, convinced that my peers and professors would share in this love of knowledge and learning; challenging stereotypes and assumptions and championing critical thinking. I was surprised to learn that this would not be the case in most of my classes and that most of my peers could care less.

To many people, college is nothing but a perquisite to obtaining a well paying job. Not for the love of learning.

I sit in class after class hoping that my professors will lead engaging and thoughtful discussions and that my peers will join in; voicing their opinions and trying to understand each other's point of view. But this rarely takes place. It seems both professors and students are rooted in the closed minded mentalities of what they "once knew" or were "once told" and this often comes at the expense of teachable moments in the classroom.

College shouldn't be solely about exams, scores and grades on report cards.
Students should come to college expecting to get a liberal education where their previous views are challenged, so that they may become more knowledgeable and sympathetic towards the world around them.

But in many classes racism, sexism and homophobia are not only ignored, but tolerated and promoted. Instead of challenging students to think critically about these issues professors often times reinforce and reward students who hold intolerant and uncritical views. It's lonely feeling like you are the only student who came to college to learn something. Hopefully many more students will begin to take advantage of the liberal education afforded to them and avoid this fate.

However at this point, I feel alone in this pursuit.


Derrick McMahon is a senior history education student from Frostproof, Fla. He can be reached at famuanopinions@gmail.com.

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

15 comments

dre'
Thu Oct 22 2009 11:02
while i don't always agree with rattlertopia, he/she is spot on with this one. derrick talks about the lack of scholarly thinking, yet this article (and others he's written) shows that he's only contributing to this problem. i often see people writing in the comments, "stop correcting the writer's spelling/punctuation/etc.," but the reality is that this is a collegiate level publication. there is no excuse for such elementary errors.

yes, a bachelor's degree is just a prerequisite for a well-paying (and sometimes not so well-paying) job. that's why you can have the many diploma mills that you see advertised on television. they're not interested in stimulating your mind. they're there to get you started on your career. the reality is that most undergraduate programs generally don't give you that stimulating conversation. you'll have to go beyond the bachelor's degree for that. a bachelor's degree is often just a small step above a high school diploma in many fields.

Rattlertopia
Wed Oct 21 2009 10:17
and it should be "devoid of" in the title. :)
Rattlertopia
Wed Oct 21 2009 10:16
Loren, I would be happy to write an article on "the meaning of life and college." I did not criticize this fool's spelling... it was his malapropism (A perquisite for a "well-paying job" would be a "corner office", for instance.) There are far more atrocities in this "masterpiece" to discuss, if you like.
Your name
Tue Oct 20 2009 01:03
Rattlertopia doesn't write articles. He comments on how awful they all are. Commenting on this guy's spelling isn't exactly petty either. I mean he's saying that he's so full of brainpower that no one else at this university is on his level. The least he can do is spell things correctly.

As for being a free thinking, open minded person, I've seen enough of Derricks comments to know that he only considers "free thinking" to be his way of thinking. Ask the Pastor's Son if you have any doubts on that.

Loren
Mon Oct 19 2009 23:09
rattlertopia,

You seem awfully hostile in your comment. That's very petty of you to be correcting his spelling. Calling this man a fool for stating his opinion? How do you figure he just got all of his ideas from movies and tv shows? What makes you say his thoughts and ideas of what he wanted college to be like is a "fantasy?" Damn him for wanting to meet people who are free thinkers, open minded, etc. I think that being the smart man he is, Derrick would know if he had chosen the wrong school. Well before his season year. I want you to write an article detailing your fantastic thoughts on college.

Rattlertopia
Mon Oct 19 2009 20:46
Wow... you're a fool too. I'm quite sure your fantasy of what college "was to be" was deeply rooted in nonsensical movies and cliches you hoped were true.... some sort scholarly collective drawing circles in the sand and educating one another in some Socratic discourse. Unfortunately, becoming "actually" educated entails the discipline to endure the busy-work that's a hallmark of undergraduate courses. At your level, it's indeed a "perquisite" (I'm sure you meant prerequisite) necessary for a well-paying job. Don't worry, however. You can get your fill of omphaloskepsis and sophism outside of your undergraduate math class. If you find there aren't enough engaging students at your University, you've probably chosen the wrong school.
chellz
Mon Oct 19 2009 14:47
i was actually saying this to a special young lady the other day... being "deep" was exciting and liberating. Knowledge was refreshing, whether it came from books, or life. Now, we are so inundated with crap that we can't even imagine thinking below the surface. It's exhausting, and no longer cool. I hear the New Boyz are what's hot though lol
Ursula
Mon Oct 19 2009 14:27
You most def are NOT alone.
FAMU lady
Mon Oct 19 2009 14:11
This is true Derrick. I'm disappointed at Mr. Smith with his VAGUE statistic (according to American standards, really? Clearly this man is not lost if he was able to script what is published here. Get a grip on life, I can tell by your rude comment that you are here just for that purpose: to fly by and start a career, with no background knowledge on issues outside of your area of concentration. Nothing to pass on to your children. You, my friend, are lost!.) Also, "Student with a 3.8" (seems a bit pompous himself with that as his choice of a reply name". What4 has a point though; elaborate, stimulate our minds as we read through your concerns. Keep this going, its important.
Student with a 3.8
Mon Oct 19 2009 12:53
Well I'm glad that at least we have you good sir. The one and only scholar on FAMU's campus, the only one capable of intellectual discussion. If we didn't have pompous people like you around, FAMU would be a bleak place indeed.
What4
Mon Oct 19 2009 12:34
OK so far! Please follow this with another article in which you advance some intellectual ideas of the kind you would like to hear discussed. Model what it means to think through a topic.
Mr. Smith
Mon Oct 19 2009 11:44
College isn't supposed to inspire learning. You have yourself for that. According to America's standards, the collegiate experience is merely meant to exercise one's youth and obtain a sheet of paper that qualifies you for a job. If you need college to feel a thirst for knowledge, then you're already lost.
Hampton Grad
Mon Oct 19 2009 10:49
Geat job, it's about time someone told the truth.
Pastor's Son
Mon Oct 19 2009 09:19
You're not alone. Every day that I come to FAMU, go to FAMU's Set, and attend my classes, it is a learning experience. My reason for loving FAMU is that everywhere you go is like a classroom. I guess the more students I talk to and the more news stories and columns I write, I learn something new. I think my love for FAMU is equal to my love for Journalism because in order to challege the mind, you must be curious about your surroundings and question others about their thoughts. Nicely written opinion. BTW "could care less" should be couldn't care less. common mistake. saying someone could care less actually means they do care. Think about it.
Your name
Mon Oct 19 2009 09:18
You're not alone. Every day that I come to FAMU, go to FAMU's Set, and attend my classes, it is a learning experience. My reason for loving FAMU is that everywhere you go is like a classroom. I guess the more students I talk to and the more news stories and columns I write, I learn something new. I think my love for FAMU is equal to my love for Journalism because in order to challege the mind, you must be curious about your surroundings and question others about their thoughts. Nicely written opinion. BTW "could care less" should be couldn't care less. common mistake. saying someone could care less actually means they do care. Think about it.






log out